Four causes of water hammer, and how to prevent damage
Water hammer is never normal in the steam and condensate system and must be always considered extremely abnormal and totally unacceptable in today’s plant operation. Water hammer is not only a system issue; it is primarily a safety issue. Understanding the nature and severity of water hammer in a steam and condensate system will allow plants to avoid it’s the safety issue and destructive forces.
A greater understanding of steam system water hammer will help the plant to implement the necessary changes in steam system design, start-up, maintenance, operation and installation to eliminate water hammer. This will additionally help provide maximum safety for plant personnel, reduce maintenance cost, and reduce system downtime.
WATER HAMMER—SOMETHING THAT NEVER SHOULD OCCUR IN A STEAM SYSTEM
1. STEAM AND CONDENSATE WATER HAMMER
Water hammer is never normal in a steam and condensate system, and it is totally unacceptable in today’s plant operations. Not only is water hammer is a system issue; it is also a safety issue. Understanding the nature and severity of water hammer in a steam and condensate system will allow plants to avoid the safety risk and destructive forces.
A better understanding of steam system water hammer will help the plant implement the necessary changes in steam system design, startup, maintenance, operation, and installation to eliminate water hammer. Additionally, this will help provide maximum safety for plant personnel, reduce maintenance cost, and reduce system downtime.
In its most severe form, water hammer can injure or even cause fatalities to plant personnel.
Unfortunately, 82% of the steam systems in North America experience some type of water hammer. Many mistakenly believe that water hammer is unavoidable and a natural part of steam and condensate systems, but this statement is entirely false. If the system is properly designed and correctly operated, water hammer in any form will not occur. It is possible to have high-pressure steam systems operating without water hammer and enjoy a long operational life from the steam components.
In Figure 1, the red circles show an improper connection to the condensate header, which will generate a thermal shock type of water hammer. Instead of connecting into the side of the condensate header, the returns should enter from the top of the manifold (condensate header).
2. WHERE DOES WATER HAMMER OCCUR?
Water hammer can occur in any steam or condensate line. The steam system faces the greatest risk of water hammer during startup, when the highest level of condensate is generated during the warm-up of the steam line. If the steam line is energized too quickly without proper warm-up time, and if the condensate created during the startup is not being properly removed, water hammer will result.
The other risk of water hammer arises in a steam system when the condensate is not properly removed from steam lines during operation.
Its effects can be even more pronounced in heterogeneous or condensate biphase (flash steam and liquid condensate) systems. Condensate biphase systems contain two states: the liquid (condensate) and a vapor (flash or generated steam). The biphase condition exists in a steam system where condensate coexists with generated flash steam.
Typical examples include heat exchangers, tracer lines, steam mains, condensate return lines, and sometimes pump discharge lines.
3. RESULTS OF WATER HAMMER
The effects of water hammer cannot be underestimated, as its forces have been documented to be capable of the following results:
- rupturing pipe fittings,
- causing valve failures,
- causing heat exchanger equipment failures,
- breaking pipe welds and even rupturing piping systems,
- causing the failure of pipe supports and guides,
- bending internal system mechanisms,
- leading to flange failures,
- overstressing pressure gauges, and
- cracking steam trap bodies.
When water hammer is severe, it can result not only in damage to equipment but also in significant injury to plant personnel.
Water hammer may be occurring and yet be silent to personnel. This means water hammer is not always accompanied by audible noise that the human ear can hear. For example, a steam bubble from flash steam that is delivered into a condensate line under the condensate level in the piping system may be small, yet the collapsing bubble creates a thermal shock that is beyond the range of human hearing. However, the damage to the steam and condensate system is still occurring.
The continuing banging or audible sound accompanying water hammer should be interpreted as the way the steam system is trying to communicate with plant personnel. This audible noise should be an alarm meaning “please correct the system errors to eliminate the water hammer problem, or damage will occur.” This water hammer sound means something in the system is wrong and needs to be corrected.
Evidence gathered while conducting root cause analysis on steam component failure suggests that water hammer causes 67% of premature component failures.
4. CONDITIONS CAUSING WATER HAMMER
Four typical conditions have been identified as causes of the violent reactions known as water hammer:
- hydraulic shock,
- thermal shock,
- flow shock, and
- differential shock.
Each cause is described below.
4.1. Hydraulic Shock
A small percentage of the water hammer problems found in a steam system are caused by hydraulic shock. Hydraulic shock can be easily described by using the example of a home faucet. When the faucet in a home opens, a solid shaft of water moves through the pipes from the point where it enters the house to the outlet of the faucet. This could be 200 pounds of water moving at 10 feet per second, or about seven miles per hour. When the faucet is suddenly shut off, it could be compared to a 200-pound hammer coming to a stop. A noticeable “bang” is heard in the system when the faucet is closed. This shockwave sound is similar to a hammer hitting a piece of steel. The shock pressure wave of about 300 psi is reflected back and forth from end to end until the energy in the piping system dissipates.
This same action can take place in the discharge piping of a condensate pump system when pumps (electric or steam motive) are used in an on/off operation with large condensate pumping capabilities. The pumping system normally has check valves installed on the pump outlet. As the pump starts and stops, hydraulic shock can occur as the condensate flow rapidly stops, and the check valves restrict the flow in one direction.
- For condensate capacities above 12,000 lbs. per hour, use a continuous flow pumping system that incorporates a variable speed drive motor or a level control valve in the discharge line of the condensate pump (pump operates continuously).
- Use disk-type check valves on the pump discharge instead of the common swing type check valve.
One pound of steam at 0 psig occupies 1,600 times the volume of a pound of water at atmospheric conditions. This ratio drops proportionately as the condensate line pressure increases. When the steam collapses, water accelerates into the resulting vacuum from all directions with great speed.
In biphase condensate systems, steam bubbles may be introduced below the level of condensate in a condensate line. For example, a branch line from a steam trap station may be piped to the bottom of a condensate main header, as shown in Figure 2.
Example: Steam is introduced into the heat exchanger (P2) at 100 psig or 338°F, and condensate at P3 will be 338°F. When the condensate passes through the steam trap station at P4, a percentage of the liquid will flash to steam due to the low pressure/temperature relationship. When the flash steam bubble flows to P5 and is introduced below the condensate level in the condensate piping, the thermal differences will cause the flash steam bubble to collapse. During the collapsing, the water is accelerated to an extremely high speed due to the vacuum that occurred when the bubble collapsed. The result is a pinging sound or, when there is large quantity of flash steam (bubble is large), a very sharp banging sound.
- Connect into the condensate header. All condensate system branch lines must be connected into the top of the main condensate header: there is no exception. The condensate connection is at the top of the horizontal condensate main header. Never connect branch lines into a vertical condensate header.
Flow shock is most commonly caused by lack of proper drainage ahead of a steam line isolation valve or steam control valve. For example, consider a steam line isolation valve (typically used with pipe of 3” or larger) opened without the use of a warm-up valve. When the large valve is opened, steam rushes down a cold pipe, producing a large quantity of condensate at high velocity. This condensate will continue to build in mass as it travels along the pipe, and a large wave of condensate is created. The wave will travel at a high velocity until there is a sudden change in direction, possibly an elbow or valve in the line. When the condensate changes direction, the sudden stop will generate water hammer.
When a steam control valve opens, a slug of condensate enters the equipment at a high velocity. Water hammer is produced when the condensate impinges on the heat exchanger tubes or walls.
- Install and use a warm-up valve, as shown in Figure 5.
- Install a steam line drip leg pocket with a steam trap station ahead of the isolation valve.
These recommendations will prevent water hammer during startup, and it will promote long valve life.
Differential shock, like flow shock, occurs in biphase systems or the condensate system. It occurs whenever steam and condensate flow in the condensate line at different velocities. In biphase systems, the velocity of the steam is often 10 times the velocity of the liquid. If condensate waves rise and fill a pipe, a seal is formed temporarily between the upstream and downstream side of the condensate wave. Since the steam cannot flow through the condensate seal, pressure drops on the downstream side. The pressure differential now drives the condensate seal at a high velocity downstream, accelerating it like a piston. As it is driven downstream, it picks up more liquid, which adds to the existing mass of the slug, and the velocity increases.
Just as in the example above, the slug of condensate gains high momentum and will be forced to change direction due to an elbow or a valve in the line. The result is usually great damage when the condensate slug pounds into the wall of a valve or fitting while changing direction.
Since having a biphase mixture is possible in most condensate return lines, correctly sizing condensate return lines becomes essential. Condensate normally flows at the bottom of a return line with the assistance of gravity. Condensate flows naturally because of the pitch in the pipe and because the higher-velocity flash steam above it pulls it along. The flash steam moves at a higher velocity because it moves by differential pressure.
Flash steam occurs in the condensate return lines when condensate discharges into these lines that are operating at a lower pressure. The lower pressure causes a percentage of the condensate to flash back to steam at the given saturation pressure. If the lines are also undersized, additional pressure is created in the line. This pressure pushes the flash steam at relatively higher velocities toward the condensate receiver, where it is vented to the atmosphere.
The flash steam loses heat while moving in the line, causing some of the flash steam to condense and contributing to the pressure differential and amplifying the velocity. Because the flash steam moves faster than the condensate, it makes waves. As long as these waves are not high enough to touch the top of the pipe and do not close off the flash steam’s passageway, there is no problem. This is why larger condensate return lines are preferred. To control differential shock, the condensate seal must be prevented from forming in a biphase system.
Condensate line velocities (two-phase flow) should never exceed 4,500 fpm. If the condensate line is properly sized for the liquid and flash steam, but the plant does not have a proper steam trap management program and steam traps are failed and blowing steam into the condensate line, this will contribute to increasing velocities above 4,500 fpm, and water hammer will occur in the system.
- Use condensate lines sized for 4,500 fpm or less.
- Institute a steam trap station management program to eliminate unnecessary steam from being introduced into the condensate line.
OTHER METHODS OF PREVENTING OR RESOLVING WATER HAMMER
A variety of design or system changes can be implemented to prevent or eliminate water hammer:
- Implement proper training for plant personnel.
- Ensure the correct steam and condensate design.
- Have documented standard operating procedures (SOPs) for steam system startups and shutdowns.
- Have installation standards for steam components.
- Specify and place steam line drip steam traps on the steam system properly.
- Correct condensate connections of branch lines to the main condensate line and enter only from the top.
- Use steam traps that are properly sized and appropriate for the application.
Figure 7. Standard Drip Leg Installation
Use warm-up valves on steam line isolation valves larger than 2 inches. Do not crack open large steam isolation valves with the hope of avoiding condensation-induced water hammer. This will not guarantee safe operation.
- Check or repair the pipe insulation. It saves energy and reduces the accumulation of condensate in the piping system.
- Condensate line sizing is crucial to ensure proper operation of the steam system. Undersizing the condensate lines is one of the largest contributors to water hammer.
- All steam valves that can be in the closed position must have proper drip legs on the steam line to remove any condensate buildup in the closed position.
- Always direct condensate gravity drainage away from the process applications with a modulating control valve.
- Condensate can be drained into a pressurized condensate return line only if the proper differential is maintained.
- Properly label the steam and condensate lines.
- Remove abandoned steam and condensate lines from the system.